Thanks for the reply.
What exactly about the layout makes it seem so outdated to you? And could you elaborate on the whole 'hurt my eyes' bit? I'm not exactly sure how to take that as constructive.
Keep the target audience in mind - this is an online game, geared towards the 13-20 age range. The bold typeface was a deliberate choice because of that.
As for side-menus and such, those will follow on the members pages. The link provided is just for the landing page. Once I fine tune that, I will develop the actual layout of the members content, which will undoubtedly contain a proper logo, navigation system, etc. I basically just want a critique on the style and feel of this landing page to use as a springboard for the main content of the site.
Thanks again for your comment.