The mix of mspaint graphics with photoshop "3d" effects is not a good combination.
Remove the 3D "crescent" and redo the main logo to be a flat effect, maybe just do it with text in an <h1> tag.. Then it will have a really true to 1995 nostalgic vibe!
Or you could replan it and make it more modern but hey that might not be the direction you are trying to go in.